The risk index, in the open
Every criterion, weight and band is published before the first score goes live. If we ever change this page, the change gets dated. Trust is the product — methodology is how you audit it.
The six criteria
| Criterion | Weight | What we check |
|---|---|---|
| Payout verification | 30% | Consistent, recent, evidenced payouts (statements, public payout walls, community attestation). The single most important signal — see the MyForexFunds case study. |
| Regulatory & legal history | 20% | Enforcement actions, corporate registration status, jurisdiction exposure. |
| Rule stability & transparency | 20% | How often rules change without notice; clarity of drawdown, consistency and payout rules. |
| Complaint density & resolution | 15% | Pattern analysis of public complaints (Trustpilot, Reddit, forums) and how firms resolve them. |
| Data freshness | 10% | How recently every input was re-verified. Stale evidence decays a score. |
| Corporate footprint | 5% | Domain age, entity structure, support responsiveness. |
Score bands
- A — Strong evidence base (80–100): verified payouts, clean history, stable rules.
- B — Generally solid (65–79): verified payouts with minor caveats or limited history.
- C — Mixed signals (50–64): real concerns that a careful trader can navigate.
- D — Elevated risk (<50): unverified payouts, history of disputes, or rule instability.
- Unrated: evidence insufficient. Every profile starts here.
A score publishes only after the evidence pass is complete. “In review” is not a soft score — it means we are not ready to stand behind a number.
Integrity rules
- Affiliate commissions never affect a score, a ranking or the order of a list.
- No firm can pay for placement, review speed, or score changes. There is no “sponsored review”.
- Scores are re-run when a firm changes rules; material changes are flagged in the deals digest.
- Corrections are logged publicly on this page with dates.
- When we are wrong, we say so here.
Corrections log: empty at launch. We would rather keep it that way than protect an ego.